By Kundan Jha | NEW DELHI | 18 February, 2017
By Kundan Jha | NEW DELHI | 18 February, 2017
A full year since becoming the Vice-Chancellor (VC) of unarguably the most politically charged university in the country, Kumar finds himself in the eye of a storm, during which he has been accused of cutting the admission seats and called a “Sanghi”—a follower of the right-wing Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) ideology—by the agitating students.
The University Grants Commission (UGC) notification adopted by the university entails an upper cap on the number of students a faculty member can guide. But as Kumar observed,
So, how could the clause of upper cap be applied without cutting down the number of students?
Kumar says that those faculty members with “excess of students” will not get any new students until the existing ones pass out, and additional vacancies are created. He emphasises that even after allocating students across the faculty, including among those who have none or less than what is prescribed now, there will still be excess students pursuing Ph.Ds and M.Phils.
“In Ph.D it takes time to complete the thesis. If we keep on admitting the same number of students, let’s assume, in five years there will be about 150 students. Where will they go? No university does that,” he added.
“I have no clue why they think so, you need to ask them,” says Kumar about the protesting teachers. He adds that “UGC is the funding agency for all central universities” and that “we are paying far more fellowship amount than what UGC gives us because of the excess of students, whereas it gives us a fixed amount”.
One of the issues which students list with the capping clause is not having any freedom to choose their guide themselves, which is chosen according to the specialty” of the professor and “research topic” of the students, as one student leader told IANS earlier.
“If a students comes to me and says that he wants to do a Ph.D. in analog electronics, and if I don’t have a faculty member with a vacancy under him in that department, I may ask him to pursue a Ph.D. in digital electronics. He may choose to do so or he may not. In the latter case, he’ll look for some other institute where there is a vacancy in his chosen field. This is the norm everywhere,” he explained.
“People are entitled to their opinions. They are free to call me anything, it won’t turn me into that. I have no political affiliations. I am just an academician focused on my research and committed to my students,” Kumar said.
Jawaharlal Nehru University vice-chancellor M Jagadesh Kumar on Monday said the demands of agitating students are “unacceptable” as every university has to adopt the 2016 UGC gazette putting a cap on number of students a faculty can guide.
Students have been sitting in protest at the administrative building since Thursday and are demanding that the VC meets them to discuss their concern over seat cut in the university due to adoption of the UGC rules.
“Students are adamant that we should not consider the 2016 UGC gazette. This is totally unacceptable. Because there are close to 800 universities and all have adopted it. JNU cannot differ because we get funding from same source, which is UGC,” Kumar said on Monday.
The VC also warned that if students continue to remain adamant and disrupt the functioning of university then he will be forced to take “appropriate action”.
“Let me tell you very firmly that law of the land will take its course. Preventing government official from doing their duty and occupying a government building is a criminal offence. We do not want our students to indulge in criminal offence and face the consequences,” he said.
The VC said admission to MPhil and PhD prorgammes will depend on vacancies. As per the UGC gazette, a professor can guide 8 PhD students and 3 MPhil students while an associate professor can guide 6 and 2 students, and an assistant professor can guide 4 and 1 students, respectively.
“PhD students can enrol only if there are vacancies. It is not a right that every student who is studying MA or MPhil will get into PhD. It is linked to the vacancies and that is linked to faculty number,” he said.
JNU students’ union said the university has an integrated MPhil/PhD and promotion to PhD or second year of MPhil is based on grades scored in previous semester.
“In no way can the JNU administration alter this criterion and bring in supervisor-scholar ratio as conditionality,” said JNUSU general secretary Satarupa.
On the issue of already registered students, the VC said, “After you adopt the UGC gazette there will be a transition period…one or two year. We will do everything possible so that interest of students already registered is protected.”
The VC said “a small section of students” are spreading the “rumour” that there is going to be a large seat cut. “It is totally unfound,” he said.
Indian Express, 27 January 2017 by ARANYA SHANKAR